Guinan and picard relationship

Guinan (Star Trek) - Wikipedia

guinan and picard relationship

Guinan came aboard the Enterprise-D in , at Captain Picard's personal request. Guinan and Picard shared a long-time relationship, which, according to . They don't really go into the exact nature of their relationship. But its been shown numerous times that Picard values her opinion and she may. I am watching Time's Arro2 and am curious, what exactly is the relationship with Picard to Guinan? It supposedly goes beyond friendship and.

Guinan assures Picard that, due to her experience with the Borg, "Humanity will survive" even if only a handful of humans live to "keep the spirit alive". Guinan also plays a role in the second part which started the fourth season.

guinan and picard relationship

She tells him that her relationship with Picard "goes beyond friendship and beyond family". Meanwhile, on the Enterprise-D, Guinan advises Picard that he must lead the away team to travel through a temporal rift to save Data in the past. Guinan reveals that her father is still alive at the time, having previously been hiding from him on Earth during "Time's Arrow". Her people, sometimes called "listeners", had been scattered throughout the galaxy after the Borg invaded their homeworld.

This is part of the opening act of Star Trek Generations, the film made after the series' seven-year run concluded. Guinan reveals in Star Trek: Nemesis that she has been married 23 times.

More Stories

She states in " Evolution " that she has many children, including a son who went through a phase when "he wouldn't listen to anybody"—something unusual "in a species of listeners".

In " Yesterday's Enterprise ", which involves a disruption of the timeline, Guinan is able to sense the disruption, even though everyone else believes it to be the natural course of events. As later explained in Generations, an echo of her is left inside the Nexus, which is said to exist outside of time.

In that film, its not clear however if Picard is just experiencing what he wants, to talk with Guinan and rescue the Enterprise with Kirk. At the time no one knew if this would be the last film, which made it more likely the timeline continued, but if had been the actual end like Nemesis was, this reading of what happened is more obvious.

Picard was only seeing a Nexus-created sequence of events according in that interpretation. If he did leave, then it means he also left echo-Picard in the Nexus, and may finally explain the mysterious relationship "deeper than friends or family"-part of each is stuck in the Nexus together.

One of the more extreme interpretations is that Guinan was imagined by Picard after he was killed was similar to B'Elanna Torres near-death experience in " Barge of the Dead ", where in the Star Trek universe people have naj; a dream-like hallucination before actual death.

guinan and picard relationship

This may have happened to Picard before in " Tapestry ". One problem is that there is logical do-loop created when Picard stops himself from ever entering the Nexus, how does he leave it? Because the Nexus is not fully explained, it may be part of its nature, or Guinan may simply have been part of his near-death dream before the Star destroys that solar system.

Guinans relationship with Picard | SFF Chronicles forums

The continuation of movies makes it more clear that the timeline continued at least until Nemesis. Countdown bridging the gap to the Kelvin reboot timeline in Star Trek If the Nexus could be found in that timeline, it might be possible to access Picard, Guinan and Kirk nexus "echos" since it can survive across time alterations. Enter Guinan to calmly explain racism to Picard.

The best moment from this conversation is when Picard figures out what Guinan is saying and calls slavery, you know, slavery. Then Guinan says "I think that's a little harsh" specifically to test Picard's wokeness. He passes, but he still had to have slavery spelled out for him so, uh Video of guinan stabs q Guinan forks Q These are two moments, but they are effectively the same greatness so I'm considering it a tie.

Guinan is, to our knowledge, at least years old. She may be way older, though. And she did a lot in those centuries. She hung out on Earth in the 19th century, she had a Tarcassian razor beast as a pet, and she used to be besties Talk about shows I wish I could see: Which is the better moment?

  • Guinan and Picard?

In the former we find out Q and Guinan were buds, which is amazing, but the latter involves Q getting forked by Guinan. I leave this Guinan's Choice to you. And that's basically the speech Guinan gives to Riker.

Guinans relationship with Picard

It's also the first time she talks about how she and Picard's relationship goes deeper than friendship or family, which We are all aware that Guinan's people were nearly wiped out by the Borg, yes? Just a bunch of pasty colonizers rolling up, destroying her world and assimilating her people into robotic, slave drones. And it isn't made any more subtle by the fact that this conversation over the fate of a young assimilating Borg, Hugh, is between two people of color.

It is understandable, I feel, that Guinan is not interested in humanizing Hugh. As she says, when Hugh's "big brothers" come for him, "they won't stop until they destroy us. But Geordi, whose job it is to turn Hugh into a walking bomb, has spent time with Hugh, and now the waters are muddy for him.

Guinan and Picard? | The Trek BBS

Geordi is getting through to Hugh. And if he can pull one young Borg and deprogram him, isn't there a chance for the others? It's not so cut and dry, in Geordi's view.

Ultimately, Guinan does speak with Hugh and sees shades of humanity in him. But, I think Guinan's first assessment of the Borg and Hugh is more honest and true to life. And true to the world we're living in right now, if you want to get really real today. Just because you calmly explain that white supremacy is bad to one young Nazi doesn't make Nazis go away.